Be careful who you challenge

The Rocketry Forum

Help Support The Rocketry Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

BruceS

Would you like a jelly baby?
TRF Supporter
Joined
Jul 21, 2019
Messages
438
Reaction score
613
Location
Billerica, MA
So I got this photo in a message with the caption: "I dare you".
So challenge accepted.
 

Attachments

  • FB_IMG_1691958601491.jpg
    FB_IMG_1691958601491.jpg
    91.5 KB · Views: 0
I picked the main ship to do. I made the disc wing in cad and had it 3d printed. Epoxied in place and Tamiya paste to smooth out.
 

Attachments

  • PXL_20230729_005708191.MP.jpg
    PXL_20230729_005708191.MP.jpg
    4.1 MB · Views: 0
  • PXL_20230729_012824132.jpg
    PXL_20230729_012824132.jpg
    1.3 MB · Views: 0
Oopsie! I saw this on Facebook awhile back. Thought you were building another. Ditch the NO GOOD, STINKING, PERFORMANCE ROBBING NOSE WEIGHT! Ditch the motor in back! This is a silly oddroc! The dark side flows strong with this one. :)
Wanted to share it here and had forgotten. I am building another. Waiting for the 3d printing to be done. W/o nose weight completely unstable.
 
It looked stable off the pad but the problem is the big wing, I mean fin, so far forward that even at a slight angle of attack it goes airplane. Loopy. Like a nasty Estes SR71.

I always asked my old RSO why do airplane rockets want to fly like airplanes? Gosh darn it! They are model rockets! I just can't figure it out! ... He never gave me an answer. Big fins up front are cool!

Pull, don't push you big wing, I mean fin, up!
IMG_20151121_124448234.jpg
Tractor motors rule!

As you progress to the Dark Side then mid cant cluster with a boat load of stinking nose weight.
FB_IMG_1623038864977.jpg
And then, just push it up...you say what?
FB_IMG_1626664275341.jpg
They even had trouble with The Flying Pancake Vought V 173 back in the day.

Widely spaced pods will work too but YIKES! I am scared.

You can do it!

Vertically launched saucers are cool!

Our old RSO: "No fricking motors taped to Frisbees!"
 
It all depends on looks, because looks are the most important.

#3, bottom of the picture above. Two canted tractors up front. Two in widely spaced pods/platters. Still might need nose weight. Like the Dornier.
IMG_20140620_213506744.jpg

#2 middle picture. Three smaller canted tractors up front where fins are.

#1. Top picture. Make the platter a little thicker to house two canted motors. Rear eject or vented to body tube. Yes Mr. RSO, it is just a Deuces Wild with a few mods. Totally safe! Cant angle between CG and CP. Can fly on one motor! POSSESSES HALLMARKS OF GOOD ROCKET DESIGN!
 
After spin test I gave it a silver coat.
So the rocket successfully passed a swing test? Did you balance it with the nose downward 10 to 15 degrees?

What was the orientation of the rocket during the test? Was the disc parallel to the Earth, or 90 degrees to the Earth?

Rocket Stability Diagram by Vern Estes.jpg
 
Parallel. Part of the problem is that just prior to painting I had left it in the car on a nice sunny day. The PLA disc developed some interesting ripples.
 
Back
Top