I used some of the Rustoleum metallic chrome recently, and it tends to flake off with the tape, even after I thought it had totally cured for a couple of days. I think you might have better luck with the metallic silver. Or, maybe try to paint a clear-coat on top of the metallic before you mask for another trim color.
(hcmbanjo talked about this on his model rocket building blog recently regarding metallic chrome paints and masking over them, which I read about right after I discovered the problem first hand myself.)