boatgeek
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 27, 2014
- Messages
- 7,415
- Reaction score
- 7,969
If I'm honest , I'm not particularly impressed. A small rocket with first landing stage.If taking off every two days and was building a big ship in orbit - then I'd be impressed.Russians launch more Soyuz than SapceX falcons per year.Even people on board. And for decades.Where is the settlement on Mars? With such a flight can not be driven into orbit only food for 2 persons for human orbital flight around Mars.What nonsense Musk flight to Mars in one direction? First you need to make orbital flight testing. Then to send a lot but much equipment. And only then a man on Mars. This is not the moon, flying off from there is very difficult. And conditions are not better than those on the moon. No food, no air, no pressure. No spacesuit - dead.No food- dead. No air- dead.The air say will be recycled. But we have very very air reserve. Food would be produced there. As in the movie Martian. It will happen but many attempts and failures. Mars need to be brought tens of tons of food and air. And other equipment. To have a manned flight there any sense. Do not die of hunger or lack of breath even survive the landing.
That's sort of like saying a Ford Focus is a terrible car because you can't use it to haul all of your possessions and your house on a trailer. A Focus might still be a useful car for you, just for commuting rather than shipping stuff. You'd use a semi to move your house. Also, Falcon 9 delivers about 22+ MT to low earth orbit, while Soyuz delivers 6-8 MT. There's nothing wrong with Soyuz; it's purpose is to lift 6-8 MT to LEO, but the Falcon 9 is a more capable launcher and definitely not "small". The only operational rockets with more capacity are the Delta IV Heavy (28+ MT) and the Angara A5 (24+ MT). Falcon 9 will carry people in the near future, and will do it at a fraction of the cost of Soyuz, particularly once stages are re-usable.
The Mars Colonial Transporter ships are on the drawing board, but nobody will start building them until there is an income stream to support it.