The_Lone_Beagle
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2014
- Messages
- 716
- Reaction score
- 5
I recently started substituting basswood for the balsa fins in my kits (it started when a kit came with balsa (or is it "tung")) that was so soft the wood flexed alarmingly!). I was about to build another kit this way, and decided to weigh the basswood, to see how much heavier/different it was from balsa.
The model this time was a Quest Big Dog...it has 4 large fins. It came with one-eighth inch balsa fins, so for this kit I also went with one-eight inch basswood (I likely could have used 3/32, but I wanted to make this weight comparison--I'll likely cut and weigh 3/32 fins soon as well). If you put 2 fins back to back (after having flipped one), it forms a parallelogram, with a height of 3.625 inches and a base of 6 inches, so 2 fins have an area of 21.75 inches, so for one fin A=10.875. Using a gram scale, the average weight of each basswood fin (more on this below) was 9.65 grams, so an average weight per sq.in. was 9.65g/10.875sq.in.=0.887 etc., let's round to 0.89 grams/sq.in.
This compared to balsa, where each fin averaged 5.5 grams (almost half the weight), so the same calculation yields 5.5/10.875=0.5057 etc., so we can round to 0.51 grams/sq.in.
These weight differences don't seem to be big considerations for mid-powered rockets. People with low power flights or wanting to achieve higher altitudes or compete in something likely would want to stick with balsa.
However, the "big" news was, regarding the basswood--I cut the 4 fins from two different sheets (2 from each sheet). Somewhat surprisingly, one set of fins averaged about 20% heavier than the other set (basswood sheet A fins avg = 8.75, basswood sheet B fins avg = 10.55).
So, the lesson here seems to be, cut fins from one sheet, and be critical of the quality of the wood, whether it is basswood or balsa. Again, for a mid-power build, a couple of grams here or there likely won't have a huge impact, but for low power and very low weight rockets, you may have to be more careful. I found this below quote from YORF, back from 2006:
"I am picky about my Balsa however, and scour all of the hobby shops I visit (even while on vacation and business) for ' C grain' balsa. I find C grain balsa to provide the best of both worlds: strength, low weight, and a certain toughness due to the swirly grain. (My wife says: "You fingered every piece of balsa in this case and you are buying just two sheets???")"
So, phew, I was starting to think I might run out of things to obsess about...
The model this time was a Quest Big Dog...it has 4 large fins. It came with one-eighth inch balsa fins, so for this kit I also went with one-eight inch basswood (I likely could have used 3/32, but I wanted to make this weight comparison--I'll likely cut and weigh 3/32 fins soon as well). If you put 2 fins back to back (after having flipped one), it forms a parallelogram, with a height of 3.625 inches and a base of 6 inches, so 2 fins have an area of 21.75 inches, so for one fin A=10.875. Using a gram scale, the average weight of each basswood fin (more on this below) was 9.65 grams, so an average weight per sq.in. was 9.65g/10.875sq.in.=0.887 etc., let's round to 0.89 grams/sq.in.
This compared to balsa, where each fin averaged 5.5 grams (almost half the weight), so the same calculation yields 5.5/10.875=0.5057 etc., so we can round to 0.51 grams/sq.in.
These weight differences don't seem to be big considerations for mid-powered rockets. People with low power flights or wanting to achieve higher altitudes or compete in something likely would want to stick with balsa.
However, the "big" news was, regarding the basswood--I cut the 4 fins from two different sheets (2 from each sheet). Somewhat surprisingly, one set of fins averaged about 20% heavier than the other set (basswood sheet A fins avg = 8.75, basswood sheet B fins avg = 10.55).
So, the lesson here seems to be, cut fins from one sheet, and be critical of the quality of the wood, whether it is basswood or balsa. Again, for a mid-power build, a couple of grams here or there likely won't have a huge impact, but for low power and very low weight rockets, you may have to be more careful. I found this below quote from YORF, back from 2006:
"I am picky about my Balsa however, and scour all of the hobby shops I visit (even while on vacation and business) for ' C grain' balsa. I find C grain balsa to provide the best of both worlds: strength, low weight, and a certain toughness due to the swirly grain. (My wife says: "You fingered every piece of balsa in this case and you are buying just two sheets???")"
So, phew, I was starting to think I might run out of things to obsess about...