You might also try making your own paper ply (plypaper?). Start with a couple sheets of 110# card stock or poster board. Remember that, just like wood, paper does usually have a "grain" to it - it will tear easily and relatively straight along the grain and not against it. It will also roll easier along the grain than against it (one reason I always design my models with the tubes oriented top to bottom).
I'm not sure how thick posterboard is, but 110# card is .009" to .010" thick, so you can judge by that how many layers you want. The next trick is to alternate the direction of the grain, just like in plywood. Not only does this make the plypaper stronger, it also reduces curling (the paper will want to curl across the grain). If you like, you can even rotate the paper 45 degrees for a couple layers to make it really strong, but that isn't really necessary. Then, it is just a matter of gluing layers together until the ply is as thick as you want. I like about 6 layers - that gives a ply from .054" to .06" thick. Eight layers would be about .072" to .080". Remember to keep the glue layer thin (I like to use an old credit card as a squeegee) and press the end product under a couple of heavy books until dry. Once dry, the stuff should easily be as tough as the fin stock that Centuri used. When building ply, try to stay with an even number of layers - that will help control the curling the best.
One caveat - If you use white glue, don't leave your rockets in a hot car for very long - the glue softens with heat and the fins could de-laminate (I've had some do that). Yellow glue might very well be more resistant to that, but I haven't tried using it. If you do, spread it thing just like white glue - treat it just the same as white glue in making your ply.
By the way, if you don't have a digital micrometer, you might want to get one - it is a really useful tool for rocket building. If you have a Harbor Freight near you, they have them pretty cheap. With a micrometer, you can customize your ply to whatever thickness you want, can measure other fiber fins to see how thick they should be (the Estes Viking is pretty much the same fiber stock that Centuri used) and even try other papers/cardboards.
Good luck and have fun!