Can you change delay on a single use motor?

Nytrunner

Pop lugs, not drugs
Joined
Oct 15, 2016
Messages
8,012
Reaction score
3,763
Location
Huntsville AL
What if you want zero delay in the case of using the SUM as a Booster stage. In my case I use Avionics to do dual deployment and I want to stack 2 F52-5C motors on a 2inch Homemade 2.4 lb rocket. Can I eliminate or minimize the delay for two stage vehicle?

There are not zero-delay composite motors. Composites have a core (hole) up through the middle that exposes the front bulkhead (and delay grain) to the full chamber pressure.

Drilling the delay of a composite motor too short (under 3-4 seconds) is a smooth way to have your rocket start burning out both ends.

Composite staging is achieved using electronics set to ignite the upper stage(s) at or shortly after Booster burnout.
 
Joined
Oct 29, 2022
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
Maryland
There are not zero-delay composite motors. Composites have a core (hole) up through the middle that exposes the front bulkhead (and delay grain) to the full chamber pressure.

Drilling the delay of a composite motor too short (under 3-4 seconds) is a smooth way to have your rocket start burning out both ends.

Composite staging is achieved using electronics set to ignite the upper stage(s) at or shortly after Booster burnout.


So remove Powder charge in booster and ignite second stage with Aux out of my Avionics package. I have that ability with a time delay charge set on a liftoff time + Burntime and allow .5 delay for some coast time. So I can remove the F52 deployment charge and epoxy the hole shut then?
 

Nytrunner

Pop lugs, not drugs
Joined
Oct 15, 2016
Messages
8,012
Reaction score
3,763
Location
Huntsville AL
So remove Powder charge in booster and ignite second stage with Aux out of my Avionics package. I have that ability with a time delay charge set on a liftoff time + Burntime and allow .5 delay for some coast time. So I can remove the F52 deployment charge and epoxy the hole shut then?

That scheme should work!
 

dhbarr

Amateur Professional
TRF Supporter
Joined
Jan 30, 2016
Messages
8,716
Reaction score
3,105
So remove Powder charge in booster and ignite second stage with Aux out of my Avionics package. I have that ability with a time delay charge set on a liftoff time + Burntime and allow .5 delay for some coast time. So I can remove the F52 deployment charge and epoxy the hole shut then?
Should work fine, skip to 4:45 or so to jump straight to composites.
 

smstachwick

LPR/MPR sport flier with an eye to HPR and scale
TRF Supporter
Joined
Jul 29, 2021
Messages
2,895
Reaction score
2,914
Location
Poway, CA
Lots of opinions here. Here’s mine:

Can you? Sure, if you’re creative. Is it legal, covered by insurance, or allowed by your RSO? That’s another story. Know the answers to all of these before deciding whether to do it and commit to launching. Ask for help from those more experienced and knowledgeable than you are, and don’t try to be sneaky. That’s a good way for a mistake to shut us all down.

Whatever you decide, please do it safely. You can always pick a different rocket or a different motor.
 
Joined
Oct 29, 2022
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
Maryland
Lots of opinions here. Here’s mine:

Can you? Sure, if you’re creative. Is it legal, covered by insurance, or allowed by your RSO? That’s another story. Know the answers to all of these before deciding whether to do it and commit to launching. Ask for help from those more experienced and knowledgeable than you are, and don’t try to be sneaky. That’s a good way for a mistake to shut us all down.

Whatever you decide, please do it safely. You can always pick a different rocket or a different motor.
Well I have been simulating in OpenRocket and I could do a 3 second delay. But I am not sure about tilt as mentioned by DhBarr. Maybe should &^%$can the 2 stage idea and enlarge my motor and pull out the delay charge. I like using the dual deploy systems and prefer that over single chute at over a 1500 ft. I do not feel like chasing the rocket for a 1/2 mile. Just my preference with dual deploy systems over 24 or 36 inch chute at higher altitudes.
 
Joined
Oct 29, 2022
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
Maryland
or allowed by your RSO? . I have a certified Level 3 rocketeer that is overseeing my launches and mentoring. But he flies motors that I cannot afford nor do I have the expertise to build or launch. We have a 600 acre field that we have permission to use for test rockets and entertainment purposes with the grandkids.
 
Joined
Oct 29, 2022
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
Maryland
What is killing me is the prohibitive costs for shipping on larger mid to high power motors. I have to rely on our monthly launches to get larger motors from club members that do resale on Cesaroni motor refills. I like the Aerotech approach but their costs are also prohibitive on Mid to High power reloadable Motor casings. I am a retiree and Budget limitations have kept me in the 29mm motors for the time being. None of our local Hobby Shops (within 100 miles) sells High Power H Cesaroni refills. For my Level 1 I had to get a friend bring my H motor Cesaroni refill to the Launch because he happened to have one on hand that he had not used. The shipping costs are going to ruin the Hobby IMHO!
 

tsmith1315

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 16, 2020
Messages
3,166
Reaction score
3,347
Location
Doerun, GA
The shipping costs are going to ruin the Hobby IMHO!

Hazmat shipping is nothing new. If it were going to ruin the hobby, it would have done so decades ago. No worries there.

That said, I am in the same situation as you. I can't buy in sufficient quantity to justify the hazmat costs. There are plenty of reloads that don't require hazmat shipping, up to J impulse. Aerotech and Loki have select motors 38mm and smaller that are hazmat-free.

Check out FlightSketch.com, they offer free shipping on orders over $35.00
 

smstachwick

LPR/MPR sport flier with an eye to HPR and scale
TRF Supporter
Joined
Jul 29, 2021
Messages
2,895
Reaction score
2,914
Location
Poway, CA
What is killing me is the prohibitive costs for shipping on larger mid to high power motors. I have to rely on our monthly launches to get larger motors from club members that do resale on Cesaroni motor refills. I like the Aerotech approach but their costs are also prohibitive on Mid to High power reloadable Motor casings. I am a retiree and Budget limitations have kept me in the 29mm motors for the time being. None of our local Hobby Shops (within 100 miles) sells High Power H Cesaroni refills. For my Level 1 I had to get a friend bring my H motor Cesaroni refill to the Launch because he happened to have one on hand that he had not used. The shipping costs are going to ruin the Hobby IMHO!
I am fortunate enough to have two clubs within a doable drive that frequently have motor vendors onsite. They’re more reliable for the big regional launch events but sometimes they’ll turn up at the monthlies.

So hazmat isn’t a universal concern, plenty of people can buy on-site or pick up orders on launch day. Others will make do with what’s available non-hazmat, or bite the bullet and cough up.
 

Neutronium95

Well-Known Member
TRF Supporter
Joined
Jan 17, 2010
Messages
767
Reaction score
775
What is killing me is the prohibitive costs for shipping on larger mid to high power motors. I have to rely on our monthly launches to get larger motors from club members that do resale on Cesaroni motor refills. I like the Aerotech approach but their costs are also prohibitive on Mid to High power reloadable Motor casings. I am a retiree and Budget limitations have kept me in the 29mm motors for the time being. None of our local Hobby Shops (within 100 miles) sells High Power H Cesaroni refills. For my Level 1 I had to get a friend bring my H motor Cesaroni refill to the Launch because he happened to have one on hand that he had not used. The shipping costs are going to ruin the Hobby IMHO!

Motors are expensive, and will continue to get more expensive for the foreseeable future.

Fortunately, there are at least a few ways to save a bit of money here and there.

First, shop around. Many vendors offer discounts, with Balsa Machining offering 25% off of high power reloads if you preorder them. If you pay $30 a year for Wildman Club, you can get non hazmat hobbyline G reloads for $17.50. Wildman also has a great sale every year around Black Friday, with deeper discounts available to club members on Wednesday, and slightly less good prices for everyone else on Saturday. There are also some vendors that don't offer good prices, to the point of marking motors up significantly above MSRP.

Secondly, look for deals on used motor hardware and second hand motors. I picked up a 29/40-120 case on here for $40 a few months back. I mostly look at the yard sale section on here, but I believe that there are also Facebook groups, and your local club members might also want to sell some stuff.

Thirdly, there are options to avoid Hazmat shipping, that aren't always apparent. All Cesaroni motors need the Hazmat fee, but many Aerotech and Loki motors up to J impulse don't need it. Hazmat fees are based off of the mass of the largest piece of propellant, so for example, most of the G reloads for the 29/40-120 casing don't need the fee because they use two propellant grains, but the F reloads do, because they use a single grain longer than the G grains. Most of the Aerotech 29mm HPR style motors don't need Hazmat fees, but the denser Blackjack motors do need them. The biggest single use motors that don't need Hazmat fees are the Econojet F motors.

Finally, if you need to buy stuff that needs Hazmat shipping, buy as much as you can at once to dilute the price of shipping. It can double the price of a H reload, but is an easier pill to swallow on a larger order. Either save up to do a larger motor purchase at once, or pool orders with some friends so that you can split the shipping costs. I've been personally saving up my hobby funds for a while now in preparation for the Wildman sale, where I'm planning to buy most of my high power motors for next year.

I hope that this advice helps. I don't know what your exact fincancial situation is, but I hope that I can at least point you in the direction where your dollars will go the furthest.
 

dhbarr

Amateur Professional
TRF Supporter
Joined
Jan 30, 2016
Messages
8,716
Reaction score
3,105
Folks were drilling the delays on Single Use Aerotech motors.
Safely, thousands of times, for actual decades.
Other folks thought that was in violation of the NAR code.
Some folks pressed and pressed for tablets of stone.
NAR and Aerotech clarified the issue, as stated in post #47 above.
It is now removed from an RSO judgment call into the realm of thou-shalt-not / thus-saith-the-board.
 

Grog6

Well-Known Member
TRF Supporter
Joined
Jul 18, 2021
Messages
855
Reaction score
734
Location
Oak Ridge TN
Thanks; I missed that. So these are not meant to be modded. I'll make a note.
I haven't finished either rocket, and anything else I have will not live thru a G- motor. :)
I have to admit, the little kid in me wanted to take my Tomahawk upscale and destroy it with a G-motor, lol. But that's not cool for adults. :)
 

jimzcatz

Boss, Carolina Rocket Mafia
Joined
Jan 22, 2009
Messages
4,750
Reaction score
878
Location
North Carolina
I use the Synerjet tool, works on every motor ever made, SU or reload. But honestly, I'm not changing delays very often.
 

mtnmanak

Joined
May 5, 2020
Messages
1,742
Reaction score
2,110
What is killing me is the prohibitive costs for shipping on larger mid to high power motors. I have to rely on our monthly launches to get larger motors from club members that do resale on Cesaroni motor refills. I like the Aerotech approach but their costs are also prohibitive on Mid to High power reloadable Motor casings. I am a retiree and Budget limitations have kept me in the 29mm motors for the time being. None of our local Hobby Shops (within 100 miles) sells High Power H Cesaroni refills. For my Level 1 I had to get a friend bring my H motor Cesaroni refill to the Launch because he happened to have one on hand that he had not used. The shipping costs are going to ruin the Hobby IMHO!

Since you are in Maryland, you do have an option - plan ahead and buy motors from Wildman (Tim Lehr) during his Black Wednesday/Saturday sale (this coming weekend). Then, call them up and tell him (well, Jackie most likely) that you want him to deliver your motors at Red Glare in the spring at MDRA. They will refund your shipping and HAZMAT charges and, voilà, you will get on-sale motors with no shipping or HAZMAT fees in March/April.
 
Top