Wernher Von Braun Paper

The Rocketry Forum

Help Support The Rocketry Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

blackbrandt

That Darn College Student
Joined
Mar 18, 2012
Messages
9,281
Reaction score
60
Hey guys, I had to write a paper for school about Wernher von Braun, thought I would post it here.

Wernher Magnus Maximilian, Freiherr von Braun was born on March 23, 1912, in Wirsitz, a city in Prussian Germany (Ward, 10-12). Wernher’s father, Baron Magnus Alexander Maximilian von Braun, was associated with the German Savings Bank and Weimar Republic Cabinet, and was the Minister of Agriculture ("Capture"). His mother, Baroness Emmy von Quistorp von Braun, was a kind and loving woman.
Wernher von Braun became a baron at birth. As such, he was surrounded by servants and maids. He was the second and most gifted of three sons. He could read at age four, and learned to play piano at almost the same age. His father stated, “Sigismund and Magnus [his two brothers] are clever, but they are ordinary clever people. Wernher is a genius.” When he was eight, Wernher moved to Berlin, where he had his first experience with rockets. (Ward, 12-14)
When Wernher was 12 years old, he saw an advertisement that had a rocket on it. Inspired by this, he decided to buy six of the biggest skyrockets he could find. He then attached them to his little Radio Flyer wagon, and lit them off with a fuse. When the fuse was almost to the end, he hopped onto the wagon for the ride. When the wagon shot off, Wernher flew down the street, knocking over a lady and running into a fruit stand. He was taken into custody by the police, and, as he later recalled, was “released into the hands of the Minister of Agriculture, which was my father.” Wernher’s father was not amused and confined him to the house for two days as punishment. Wernher evidently did not learn his lesson. The same day his house arrest ended; he repeated the experiment (Ward, 14-15).
Wernher von Braun was sent to a boarding school at Ettersburg Castle in Weimar, Germany when he was 13. The school taught hands-on exposure to practical skills, like woodworking, metalworking, carpentry, stonecutting, and masonry. In his mid-teens, Wernher convinced his father to let him switch to a school near the North Sea. Wernher excelled at this school, and he graduated with honors in autumn of 1929, at the age of 17.
One of Wernher’s first jobs was working in a machine shop. Before he could become an apprentice, he had to complete a challenge. He recollected this years later when he gave the finished product to a young boy:
It is a cube. A perfect cube. It was a test. When I was a boy, older than you are now, I wanted to be an apprentice in a machine shop. They gave me a lump of steel the size of my 2 fists together and they said to make them a perfect cube. I worked for weeks. I cut, and I polished. Time after time, they measured what I had done, and gave it back to me saying it was not perfect. Do it again, they said. So I did it again and my cube got smaller and smaller. Finally it is as you see now [approximately 1.5 inch edge]. They measured it and said I had created a perfect cube. All the edges were equal. I was then permitted to become an apprentice (Johansen 130).
If this was not determinate enough, Wernher completed the task with only a file and a vise (Ward 13).
In early 1930, von Braun created a team of rocketeers called Raketenflugplatz Berlin (literally translated “Rocket Launching Site of Berlin”). This team was mentored by Hermann Oberth, a physicist and engineer (Ward 14). Oberth’s team desperately needed money (Bellis). So the Verein für Raumschiffahrt (the VfR, literally translated “Spaceflight Club”) of Germany stepped in to sponsor the group ("Braun", Britannica). By the end of the year, Oberth had to leave Germany for work purposes, and von Braun continued in Oberth’s footsteps as leader of the group (Bellis).Wernher experienced a surprise in spring of 1932. When his team was in the middle of counting down one of their test rockets, a sedan pulled up to Wernher’s launch. When it came to a halt, out stepped a general and a colonel of the German Army. The general asked von Braun if he would design missiles for the military. Wernher immediately accepted the offer (Bellis). Von Braun’s career literally skyrocketed. In 1934 his team launched the first A-2 missile to 1½ miles. The fuel was a mixture of alcohol and oxygen, which made this rocket one of the first hybrid motors ever launched. This flight got the attention of the Luftwaffe. When they learned what von Braun was doing, they offered him 5,000,000 reischmarks to develop a rocket-powered fighter jet (Ward 15-17, 19). The next rocket designed by von Braun’s team was the A-3 in 1937. It could reach 15 miles in altitude while carrying a 100-pound warhead (V-2 Rocket 1). Von Braun’s most famous missile designed in Germany was the A-4 in 1942. It was the world’s first guided ballistic missile. Nearly every aspect of the A-4 was made from scratch, including the propulsion system, the navigation (which included two vanes in the nozzle opening that moved to direct the missile), and the control mechanisms. The A-4 weighed 14 tons and was 46 feet tall, which is taller than a 4-story building. The A-4 was renamed the V-2 in 1943 by Hitler (V-2 Rocket 2). The hardest part of designing the V-2 was the engine. It had to produce enough thrust to get the rocket off the ground but not explode from overpressure. In autumn, 1944, Wernher’s team had developed a machine that produced target thrust, controlled its own trajectory, and could travel thousands of miles to hit a target. The V-2 was the first mass terror weapon, compared to earlier weapons that were strategic or tactical (V-2 Rocket 2).The first V-2 fired at London instantly demolished 6 houses, killed 3 people, and injured 22. Throughout the autumn of 1944, 4 to 6 missiles hit London every day. The deadliest V-2 attack ever killed 160 British citizens. By the end of November of 1944, over 100 V-2’s had struck London. The key behind this amazing rate was von Braun, who constructed over 700 V-2’s a month (“V-2 Rocket 3”). Von Braun’s life was not carefree though. As the end of World War II approached, Hitler knew that the V-2 rockets were not strong enough to defeat the Americans. Von Braun knew that he would be executed when the Germans lost the war, so in January, 1945, von Braun knew it was time to escape. So his team met together, and decided to surrender themselves to the Americans. But this plan was not just as easy as packing up the car and going to America. Von Braun wrote himself bogus orders to move all of the V-2 equipment and plans. On the side of the trucks, he painted VABV, which in English means Project for Special Dispositions (V-2 Rocket 3). When von Braun escaped, he and his team traveled only at night without headlights to avoid being seen. One night, von Braun’s driver fell asleep, and lost control of the car. The resulting accident instantly killed the driver and broke von Braun’s arm after the car wrapped around a tree. Von Braun was in a cast for months afterwards ("Capture").His team first stopped at Bleicheroide, where they stayed for one month (Ward 84). Then, only the team of missile experts went to Oberammergau, where they knew Americans were camped out only miles from them. On May 2, 1945, the day after Hitler’s death was made public, von Braun encountered an advance antitank patrol of the 44th infantry US Army 3rd Armored Division. Wernher sent his brother Maximilius Von Braun on a bicycle towards the Americans.
When the Americans saw Maximilius, they aimed their guns at him and ordered him to put the bike down and his hands up. In broken English, Maximilius explained that he was trying to find the Americans. The patrol was very suspicious of this story, but when they learned that his brother was Wernher von Braun, they immediately brought the team to officer’s quarters ("Capture"). Von Braun was treated well by the Americans. After all, he had the V-2 information and they didn’t (Ward 86).
Von Braun was then moved to America, where he stayed at White Sands Missile Range. He was not the only thing moved to America, though. The US army also returned with 112 scientists, 100 V-2’s, and all 14 tons of technical documents about the V-2. In 1950 von Braun was relocated to Huntsville Alabama’s Redstone Arsenal ("Capture"). Von Braun would remain here for 10 years. At the Redstone Arsenal facility, he developed the Redstone Rocket and later the Jupiter-C Rocket (Ward 125-127).
In 1960 his development center was moved from Huntsville to NASA and he received an order to build the giant Saturn rockets. Von Braun became director of NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center and also the chief architect of the Saturn V launch vehicle, the massive rocket that would propel many American astronauts to the moon (Ward 127-132).
In 1970 von Braun was asked to move to Washington, D.C. He had been assigned the job of NASA's Deputy Associate Administrator for Planning at NASA Headquarters. After several arguments concerning the termination of the Apollo program and facing severe budget cuts, von Braun finally retired from NASA on May 26, 1972 (“Braun”, History).
After retiring from NASA, von Braun became the Vice President for Engineering and Development at the aerospace company Fairchild Industries in Germantown, Maryland on July 1, 1972. He reluctantly retired from Fairchild on December 31, 1976 (“Braun” History), due to kidney cancer discovered during a routine doctor appointment. While hospitalized, he was awarded the 1975 National Medal of Science. Von Braun died from cancer on June 16, 1977, in Alexandria, Virginia. He was 65 years old (Benson).
 
It's a pretty good read; well done.

If anything, and without knowing the rubric for the assignment, I'd suggest giving the paper more balance as far as timeline. I'd give more detail on how vB helped form and guide the US space program, especially the manned missions. Most of your paper covers the WW2 era, which is obviously very important, but without him our space program would be a mere pittance of what it was.
 
BB,

You did a good job of tip-toeing around the fact that Von Braun was a Nazi. For further reading, The Nazi Rocketeers: Dreams fo Space and Crimes of War by Dennis Pixzkiewicz, ISBN:978-0-8117-3387-8, is a great read! Good Job and well written.

~Chuck
 
Thanks! The main reason I didn't go into his Nazi-ness was that the paper had a max of 5-7 pages, and that was 6.5 pages.
 
BB,

I completely understand your reasoning. I'm assuming that you wrote the paper because of his technical innovation and not his political affiliation. I think discussing it in your paper would be a little too much and some people might get the wrong idea. The only way WVB's affiliation can be discussed in today's "politically correct" world is to completely bash him. Case and point, I had a history professor say the WVB and his team were all war criminals and should have paid for their role in the Holocaust. That professor's view point was strong to say the least.

~Chuck
 
Well, the prompt was to write a biography discussing his contributions to the world.
 
Chuck you are right, he was a war criminal and a nazi, maybe just opportunistic but fact he was member of the party AND member of the SS. In fact it has been proven that he knew very well under which circumstances the rockets were built, in Peenemünde where they did the resarch & dev but also in Mittelbau Dora (Harz region) where they were produced..by concentration camp prisonners. But again, the US was also very opportunistic in the case WVB and took him and most members of his team he recommended as well as many rockets finished or in final stadium. Then they gave the production site to the Russians. The most terrible statistic is the number of dead people to produce the rocket was higher as the number of dead people in the countries where the rocket hit the ground. by the way, another great war criminal was Donberger, which was the military head of Peenemünde and which found also a great job in the US after war.
 
von Braun had about as much choice in becoming a Nazi and SS officer, in order to run the rocket program in WWII Germany, as a person wanting to be elected a judge in Texas has in "choosing" to run as a Republican. Actually, less of a choice, since in theory a Democrat can be elected a judge in Texas, but in WWII Germany he had to join the Nazi party and the SS or else be replaced.

It was a job requirement.

Now, anyone who insists he was a war criminal, then they must also insist that the US be removed from the history books for the first lunar landing, the entire Mercury and Apollo program "disqualified", like a football team winning a national championship with a player LATER declared to be ineligible (I leave out Gemini since it used a Titan-II booster and von Braun was focusing on Apollo for the most part once the Mercury-Redstone flights were done).

Maybe China CAN be the first country to "officially" land humans on the moon, then?

This would also mean the Russia is so far the only country to officially return samples of lunar soil from the moon, if the revisionists ruled the day.

Anyway, von Braun will always be one of the top heroes in the U.S. space program, despite revisionist B-S.

- George Gassaway
 
Last edited:
Georg,

I appreciate your points but may be I shall add this: it has never been mandatory to be member of SS to get into high position in nazi regime. At contrary only very few were members, trully said the hardcore believers. He was. As another example: Dornberger, which was his BOSS in Peenemünde, was General of the Army and NOT SS.
Another fact: The whole programm was "kidnapped" bei Himmler that had his own war with the Army. In fact the SS was a state in the state and much more a kind of "scientology" than anything else. Money and profit was the topic number one of the SS. So they took the production programm of the Agregat 4 (A4), called it Vergeltungswaffe 2 (V2) and started producing under the management of SS Obersturmbannführer Kammler, which was a kind of crisis manager of the SS organisation. Do not forget that the biggest problem of the A4 was the permanent modifications done in Peenemünde, that could not come into production properly.
Yes you guys did a great thing with landing on the moon with the blood of thousands and thousands of concentration camp prisoners, indirectly. Just a fact, nothing to be upset about. This is history we cannot change. By the way, the Russian did exactly the same with the V2 and German engineers and believe or not, the first chinese rocket called dongfeng 1 (east wind 1) was..a russian R2 which was..a modified A4..so also the chinese civil program has an history. And just to finish..the French had a few hundreds German engineers and sources said 20 A4 in spare parts. They joined French missile production and civil programms..that ended with Ariane.
The Father of the Viking motor of Ariane IV was Heinz Brinker, he was a staff of Dr. Thiel in Peenemünde...another one that ignored the nazi crimes..but was trully in the middle of it!
Well..so is human kind..state reason is always above moral and the history of rocketry cannot be changed.
Just one crazy point: Mr. Goddard was American and far ahead in the 30ties in rocketry.. and no one listened to him...he had no blood on his hands. He was American. He was the hero. How many do know him today?
thx and regards from Germany
Denis
PS: if you have the chance to visit Munich sometimes, go to the "Deutsches Museum" and you will see a nice rocket collection...
 
Last edited:
Very good paper. Looks like you did a lot of thorough research
 
I would like to offer one suggestion. You don't provide a reason for him changing schools in this paragraph; I think it makes sense to explain why he asked his father to let him change schools.

"The school taught hands-on exposure to practical skills, like woodworking, metalworking, carpentry, stonecutting, and masonry. In his mid-teens, Wernher convinced his father to let him switch to a school near the North Sea. Wernher excelled at this school, and he graduated with honors in autumn of 1929, at the age of 17."
 
Von Braun was probably well aware his rockets were not being manufactured by willing workers under humane conditions. He certainly was aware the A-4 was not intended for peaceful objectives.

Had he expressed any objections to this or any other policies of the Hitler regime he would have been in front of a firing squad within 15 minutes.
 
The Rocket and the Reich: Peenemünde and the Coming of the Ballistic Missle Era by Michael J Neufield is an excellent scholarly account of vonBraun's development of liquid fueled (not hybrid) rockets. https://www.amazon.com/The-Rocket-Reich-Peenem%C3%BCnde-Ballistic/dp/067477650X is the amazon listing and indicates used copies can be pruchased for less than $5. It's a must have for anyone vonBraun collection.

Bob
 
Last edited by a moderator:
von Braun had about as much choice in becoming a Nazi and SS officer, in order to run the rocket program in WWII Germany, as a person wanting to be elected a judge in Texas has in "choosing" to run as a Republican. Actually, less of a choice, since in theory a Democrat can be elected a judge in Texas, but in WWII Germany he had to join the Nazi party and the SS or else be replaced.

It was a job requirement.

Now, anyone who insists he was a war criminal, then they must also insist that the US be removed from the history books for the first lunar landing, the entire Mercury and Apollo program "disqualified", like a football team winning a national championship with a player LATER declared to be ineligible (I leave out Gemini since it used a Titan-II booster and von Braun was focusing on Apollo for the most part once the Mercury-Redstone flights were done).

Maybe China CAN be the first country to "officially" land humans on the moon, then?

This would also mean the Russia is so far the only country to officially return samples of lunar soil from the moon, if the revisionists ruled the day.

Anyway, von Braun will always be one of the top heroes in the U.S. space program, despite revisionist B-S.

- George Gassaway
I agree......
 
Regarding von Braun's Nazi and SS links, see this wiki page:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wernher_von_Braun#Involvement_with_the_Nazi_regime

" In 1939, I was officially demanded to join the National Socialist Party. At this time I was already Technical Director at the Army Rocket Center at Peenemünde (Baltic Sea). The technical work carried out there had, in the meantime, attracted more and more attention in higher levels. Thus, my refusal to join the party would have meant that I would have to abandon the work of my life. Therefore, I decided to join "

" Realizing that the matter was of highly political significance for the relation between the SS and the Army, I called immediately on my military superior ..., Dr. Dornberger. He informed me that the SS had for a long time been trying to get their "finger in the pie" of the rocket work. I asked him what to do. He replied on the spot that if I wanted to continue our mutual work, I had no alternative but to join." "

So, like I said.

Von Braun was probably well aware his rockets were not being manufactured by willing workers under humane conditions. He certainly was aware the A-4 was not intended for peaceful objectives.

Had he expressed any objections to this or any other policies of the Hitler regime he would have been in front of a firing squad within 15 minutes.

As far as knowing that the A-4 / V-2 was not intended for peaceful purposes, the same thing can be said about Robert Oppenheimer, and the rest involved with creating the first atomic bombs, including no less than Albert Einstein, and presidents Roosevelt and Truman.

I mean, the first atomic bomb killed several times more civilians than all the V-2's. Estimates vary widely but it seems to be in the 100,000 range.

I definitely agree that dropping the atomic bomb was necessary in order to end the war with Japan, rather than lose up to a million Americans in an invasion of Japan. But being necessary does not whitewash the horror of the results, with a massive loss of civilian lives and a whole city destroyed in one shot. And then done a second time when Japan didn't surrender quickly.

So if one goes by the ethics of an individual working on a weapon that was used against an enemy....

Just sayin'.......

I don't think Oppenheimer grew up as a kid wanting to develop a bomb that could kill 100 thousand or more people, and an entire city, in one drop. After the bomb was developed, he was haunted for the rest of his life (though others didn't seem to care that much). As a kid, von Braun dreamed of space travel. Not missiles, space travel. And he got to see his personal dreams come true, to a large extent, with the first US satellite (could have beat the Russians by a year if Eisenhower had not stopped it), the whole US manned space program, Lunar landings, and the first taste of a space station with Skylab. If the shuttle had been devleloped more quickly, and if he had not developed cancer, he likely would have flown on a shuttle mission.

In any case, after WW-II, more than anyone in America, von Braun helped to promote the ideas of space travel, in books, magazine articles, TV, Disney's Man in Space series, and with meetings and talks with politicians and the public, at all sorts of gatherings. In a sense, THAT is what got us to the moon first more than the Saturn-V itself. The public was willing to listen to someone like him and when the time came to actually create a space program, the public was ready and willing to support it.

He didn't do alone..... but if the team effort to sell the public on space for the future was like a football team, he'd have been the coach AND quarterback.

BTW - one reason why so few know of Goddard compared to von Braun, is he was so secretive and wanted to protect his rocket patents. Of course, he was somewhat well known in the 1930's and mid 40's, when pretty much the US public didn't know anything about von Braun. Goddard died August 1945, so he didn't have the opportunity to try to promote space or rocketry after the war. However, in his later years, Goddard did not promote space flight at all, due in large part to the ridicule he'd received from his "A Method of Reaching Extreme Altitudes", including a critical editorial in the New York Times.

- George Gassaway

disney.gif


5766603237_b6c0fd3395_z.jpg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top