woferry
Well-Known Member
To avoid hijacking the RW Rapton 38 thread or continuing to make posts on the Happy Hump Day thread, I wanted to create a thread specific to this kit. But I don't feel qualified to truly do my own build thread, I have more questions than answers when it comes to this kit so far. So I'd like to propose a "community build thread", where hopefully anyone else who ordered one of these might chip in on how they're handling certain details of the rocket. I'll start out with some questions I have.
First off, I'll note that RKeller has already put together an OpenRocket file for this kit, in this post. I haven't compared any of the weights / dimensions to my kit yet, but it looks reasonable at a quick glance.
1) Anybody have guidance on how far from the bottom of the rocket the fins should be? There are no instructions or plans provided by the vendor, I'm not sure if RKeller had any insight here or if he just guessed/eyeballed it. Is there any benefit to them being as far forward as pictured on RW's kit page? Seems like it would be an easy way to get another ~1" of CP back by moving them back, is there some other design that is the inspiration here, or is the room being left for a motor retainer, or...?
2) This is my first non-slotted fin setup, I built two previous MD rockets but they were both GLR kits with the Acme fin cans, so no learning there. The two triangular guides are provided to take care of the spacing and alignment, but I'm wondering about the actual attach to the airframe. I'm tempted to try a few dots of CA to hold the fins in place enough to remove the guides, and then apply a proper epoxy fillet the whole way around. But I also have no experience with FG (this is also my first FG kit), will CA stick the two FG parts together?
3) Still on the fins, since the colored FG lets the rocket look good without painting, I'm sensitive to putting ugly fillets on this kit. I've used 30 minute Z-poxy on my previous (wood + phenolic) builds, would that (presumably along with milled glass for strength) be good for this FG kit, or is a different epoxy needed for FG? I guess I'm going to try to figure out how to dye the epoxy black also, or is it easier to just try to paint it black afterwards? Since there is no TTW I'm also curious how big people think the fillets need to be, trying not to get carried away on an MD rocket, but it looks like it's hard to keep this kit under mach with any I motor I've sim'ed.
4) Also, is it a good idea to try to bevel these fins, or just leave them as-is? They're pretty thin (1/16"), and I suspect would look bad after trying to bevel (probably requiring painting of the fins to make look good again), so I'm leaning towards not touching them but I'm wondering if that's a bad idea.
For my build, I'm probably going to go with the Aero Pack M38E for motor retention and the wfcook/AMW fly-away rail guides to keep with the spirit of MD. I plan to skip the vent band and epoxy the upper half of the avionics bay coupler to the upper airframe (same style as the GLR Firestorm 54 bay design), where the upper bay bulkhead w/all-thread drops-in through the top of the upper airframe, and the rocket separates at the bottom of the avionics bay as well as the nose cone. I'm going to need access to the NC anyhow as I plan to put a tracker up there. I'll probably order a set of the avionics bay bulkheads without the center hole, as I'd rather drill an offset hole and use all-thread with an eye-nut at each end for the shock cord attachment, to ensure I can fit my electronics (either SLCF or EasyMini and a ~9V-sized LiPo) in the bay. And I'm thinking of APE's 38mm NC bulkhead for the top, to have an upper sled for an Eggfinder & LiPo. And for recovery probably just a streamer for the drogue and a 30" chute for the main.
First off, I'll note that RKeller has already put together an OpenRocket file for this kit, in this post. I haven't compared any of the weights / dimensions to my kit yet, but it looks reasonable at a quick glance.
1) Anybody have guidance on how far from the bottom of the rocket the fins should be? There are no instructions or plans provided by the vendor, I'm not sure if RKeller had any insight here or if he just guessed/eyeballed it. Is there any benefit to them being as far forward as pictured on RW's kit page? Seems like it would be an easy way to get another ~1" of CP back by moving them back, is there some other design that is the inspiration here, or is the room being left for a motor retainer, or...?
2) This is my first non-slotted fin setup, I built two previous MD rockets but they were both GLR kits with the Acme fin cans, so no learning there. The two triangular guides are provided to take care of the spacing and alignment, but I'm wondering about the actual attach to the airframe. I'm tempted to try a few dots of CA to hold the fins in place enough to remove the guides, and then apply a proper epoxy fillet the whole way around. But I also have no experience with FG (this is also my first FG kit), will CA stick the two FG parts together?
3) Still on the fins, since the colored FG lets the rocket look good without painting, I'm sensitive to putting ugly fillets on this kit. I've used 30 minute Z-poxy on my previous (wood + phenolic) builds, would that (presumably along with milled glass for strength) be good for this FG kit, or is a different epoxy needed for FG? I guess I'm going to try to figure out how to dye the epoxy black also, or is it easier to just try to paint it black afterwards? Since there is no TTW I'm also curious how big people think the fillets need to be, trying not to get carried away on an MD rocket, but it looks like it's hard to keep this kit under mach with any I motor I've sim'ed.
4) Also, is it a good idea to try to bevel these fins, or just leave them as-is? They're pretty thin (1/16"), and I suspect would look bad after trying to bevel (probably requiring painting of the fins to make look good again), so I'm leaning towards not touching them but I'm wondering if that's a bad idea.
For my build, I'm probably going to go with the Aero Pack M38E for motor retention and the wfcook/AMW fly-away rail guides to keep with the spirit of MD. I plan to skip the vent band and epoxy the upper half of the avionics bay coupler to the upper airframe (same style as the GLR Firestorm 54 bay design), where the upper bay bulkhead w/all-thread drops-in through the top of the upper airframe, and the rocket separates at the bottom of the avionics bay as well as the nose cone. I'm going to need access to the NC anyhow as I plan to put a tracker up there. I'll probably order a set of the avionics bay bulkheads without the center hole, as I'd rather drill an offset hole and use all-thread with an eye-nut at each end for the shock cord attachment, to ensure I can fit my electronics (either SLCF or EasyMini and a ~9V-sized LiPo) in the bay. And I'm thinking of APE's 38mm NC bulkhead for the top, to have an upper sled for an Eggfinder & LiPo. And for recovery probably just a streamer for the drogue and a 30" chute for the main.